LA CALLE DE LA AMARGURA AND DOUBTFUL ETYMOLOGIES
I am very skeptical about phraseological etymologies, since most of them must be taken with a grain of salt. Llevar (traer) por la calle de la amargura , meaning to give someone a hard time or make someone’s life miserable, is a case in point. In his novel Los vencejos (2021), Fernando Aramburu uses it thus: “... dos hijas que le traían por la calle de la amargura.” The two daughters were making his life miserable. But what is the unofficial origin? Near the Plaza Mayor, in Madrid , there was allegedly a street, calle de la amargura , through which soldiers or criminals—depending on the source—were led to execution. The idiomatic expression appeared in the DRAE in 1970. Yet Gregorio González mentions the phrase, in reference to Christ, in El guitón Onofre (1604), which gives the folk etymology the lie and shows how slow the Academia has been to register phraseology. Be that as it may, my conclusion is that folk etymologies, however colorful, should generally be mistrusted.