IS SCHOOL STILL OUT? (1)


Has the internet and technology truly changed traditional classroom education? Are students learning more, and learning better?

In 2002, while preparing the fourth volume of my English in Action, an English grammar for Spanish speakers (hispanohablantes), I wanted to make it a chrestomathy of educated English: a selection of passages designed to help learners master a language. I included poetry, short stories, newspaper articles, and literary essays.

During my research, I came across a review in the Financial Times titled “Is Education Outdated?” It discussed Lewis Perelman's School's Out: Hyperlearning, The New Technology, and the End of Education, published by William Morrow in 1992. I found the review sufficiently persuasive to obtain permission to reprint it.

According to the reviewer, Perelman argued that conventional education was obsolete and that investing in school reform was like investing in the horse and buggy at the dawn of the twentieth century while ignoring the automobile, which would soon sweep horse-drawn transport aside.

Technology, he maintained, was undermining the foundations of an educational system that had endured for centuries. He went further, describing American academic education as a costly fraud.

In his book, he wrote:

“A technological revolution is sweeping through the U.S. and world economies that is totally transforming the social role of learning and teaching. This learning revolution has already made the ‘classroom teacher’ as obsolete as the blacksmith shop.”

He added: “Learning has become too essential to the modern economy to be left to the schools.”

In a Wired interview, he went further still: “The conventional ‘technology’ of the classroom is a thousand-year-old invention initially adopted to discipline an esoteric cadre of acetic (sic) monks.”

Notice that ascetic means practicing self-denial, whereas acetic refers to vinegar and related chemical compounds. In another version of this argument, I might have made the misspelling a telling example of educational failure. But we should be fair: the error may have been the interviewer's, not Perelman's.

Tempus fugit. Here we are in 2026, almost four decades after Perelman's book appeared, and what has changed? School is still very much in session. Teaching, testing, grading, school boards, and their endless policies remain firmly in place. Educationally speaking, we are still riding the horse and buggy our parents and grandparents rode before us - along with the Amish.

Perelman was both right and wrong. His central insight remains compelling: technology has transformed access to information and the possibilities for learning. Yet the internet, cell phones, tablets, and instant access to information have not transformed classroom practice to the extent one might have expected.

Television, too, remains a great invention, even when put to poor use. Its educational potential was never fully exploited. The same may be true of the technologies that followed.

Perhaps predicting the future is a dangerous and fruitless business. Perhaps we prefer better safe than sorry and let sleeping dogs lie. Educators, like the rest of us, may fear changes that threaten established routines and our modus vivendi.

And so we still have:

  • Overcrowded classrooms.

  • Obsolete printed textbooks.

  • Irrelevant homework.

  • Outdated testing methods.

  • Teachers who stand before a class and repeat, year after year, what the textbook says.

  • Subjects poorly suited to the needs of the twenty-first century.

  • Pupils who struggle to write by hand or express themselves clearly—and who may confuse acetic with ascetic.

  • The assumption that educating the young is the school's responsibility alone.

  • The mistaken belief that education ends when we leave school.

  • Language skills that remain stubbornly stagnant.

Lifelong learning is no longer an option but a necessity. We cannot stop acquiring knowledge when we earn our degrees: facts change, knowledge expands, and information moves at an extraordinary pace.

We must adapt our teaching methods to the possibilities of technology, accept that those methods may need revising from year to year, and recognize that education extends far beyond the classroom. Otherwise, we risk missing the boat.

So, was Perelman right or wrong?

He was right about technology and wrong about education's imminent demise. Technology has changed how we obtain information, but it has not automatically changed how we teach or how we learn. The machine can be new while the method remains centuries old.

Why has this happened? I ask you. 

 

Comentarios

Entradas populares de este blog

LAS NALGAS Y SUS SINÓNIMOS COLOQUIALES

ALBERTO NÚÑEZ FEIJOO Y EL IDIOMA INGLÉS

PREFIJOS INGLESES: UN- / IN-